HARDAWAY: Lessons for the GOP to learnNovember 29th, 2008 | 5 Comments | Posted in Barack Obama, Mitt Romney, Mormons, Presidential Election, Presidential Race
|
http://www.rockymountainnews.com/news/2008/nov/26/hardaway-lessons-gop-learn/
By Robert Hardaway
Published November 26, 2008 at 12:01 a.m
It should have been a slam-dunk for the Republicans in the 2008 presidential election. After all, the Democrats had inexplicably chosen as their nominee the least-qualified candidate in American history. Indeed, the only other candidate in American history to go directly from the Senate to the White House with neither gubernatorial nor military executive experience was Warren G. Harding, by consensus the worst president in American history. Moreover, Obama’s voting record in the Senate has also been rated as the most hard-left voting record in American history.
To lose to such a candidate required more than simple ineptitude. It required an almost pathological determination to lose.
And yet, it may yet prove of value to the Republican Party if it can learn the following lessons from its defeat:
First, if you are going to go against an obviously unqualified candidate, choose a candidate with substantial executive experience. Only a handful of candidates in American history have ever succeeded to the office of the presidency without at least some gubernatorial executive experience. The Republicans had their chance to choose Mitt Romney, who not only had experience as a governor, but also experience as a business leader and organizer of the Olympics. Romney also “walked the walk” on universal health care in Massachusetts, unlike Democrats who have traditionally only talked the talk.
Second, don’t reject a candidate because of his religion. Polls of Republicans expressed greater reservations over a Mormon candidate than an Islamic one.
Third, don’t choose a man in his 70s to go up against a candidate of youth, vigor, and charisma, especially when your own candidate also has no executive experience.
Fourth, don’t assume that independent voters will vote for the candidate who best upholds such traditional values as fiscal responsibility, strong national security, protection of our borders, and limited government. We should know by now that swing voters vote on the basis of personality and television persona. Thus, Obama’s impending victory no more reflects the electorate’s turn to the hard left, than Reagan’s 49-state electoral victory in 1980 reflected a turn to the right.
Fifth, don’t insult the intelligence of the voters with simplistic characterizations of the opponent’s positions. Those only fuel counterattacks by a sympathetic media eager to show that 30-second ads do not completely set forth the complexities of the opponent’s agenda. Rather, Republican ads need only have shown, without commentary, actual videos of Obama refusing to put his hand over his heart during the playing of the national anthem, his statement that he had visited “57 states” and the town hall video in which he talked about the need for asthma suffers to get “breathalyzers” — followed by the simple question: “Ready to lead? You decide.”
Sixth, ask voters whether the old American adage still holds true—namely that one’s character is evaluated in large part by the company he keeps. And leave it at that. No need to name names.
Seventh, don’t let your party be outspent by such business tycoons as George Soros.
Eighth, and perhaps hardest of all, set aside social issues and concentrate on fiscal responsibility, national security, border protection, and fairness to the teeming millions of those seeking legal immigration. You don’t have to give up your principles on social issues, but, absent a Reagan-quality communicator as your nominee, you’re not going to win on them.
Ninth, decide whether public displays of support for such issues are worth losing an election.
And finally—at number ten— get some members of your party to audition for “Saturday Night Live.” There should be ample material (see No. 5 above).
Robert Hardaway is a professor of law at the University of Denver Sturm College of Law.
Subscribe to the Rocky Mountain News


